The big frog
This collector's item can be found in the first chapter of the second episode "Ahoy Goblins!" While cleaning the Ronan House as Alyson, walk past the kitchen to a space off the living room where you will see a wooden chair. Alyson can look under the table next to the chair where The Big Frog will be downstairs, ready to be collected.
The loyal moose
The second collector's item can be found in the “Cold Case” chapter. Searching Eddy's desk at the police station, The Stalwart Moose is found in his desk drawer.
The eating muskrat
This collectible can be found in the chapter "Plush Fight!" As Tyler, in Tessa's shop, make your way to the break room before taking on Michael's duties where there will be a cabinet with a framed photo on top. Right next to the photo, the eating muskrat is waiting for you to grab it.
The very old beaver
The fourth collector's item can be found in the “Last Rites” chapter while in the graveyard as Tyler, after finding the first gravestone, move to the next part of the area and take a left at the first path branched off towards the totem pole. Continue on the path and you will see another gravestone with a keepsake box behind it. The very old beaver is inside the box.
The moons Hag
The last collectible can be found in the final chapter "Scorched Earth". This collector's item is quite easy to spot. After you put out the fire in the barn, head to the nearby storage room and search one of the cabinets to find The Moon Hag sitting there.
If you've followed this guide accordingly, you should have easily found all of the collectibles in the second episode of Tell Me Why.
