After catching a Sea of Thieves fish, you have the option to turn it into a Hunter's Call for a reward for a flat rate, or you can increase the amount you receive by cooking it. You can also eat cooked fish to heal yourself and your teammates. The same goes for any Shark Meat, Kraken, or Megalodon you acquire during your travels. Cooking fish takes a bit of practice as there is no direct timer telling you how long you need to do it. The best way to do this is to watch how meat changes during cooking and learn how to remove it from a pan.
All you need to cook Sea of Thieves is a casserole dish that you can find on your ship's deck or campfires that you find on islands and outposts. These places should have a pan resting above the flames where you place your fish meat.
Cooking fish and shark
You will have an easier time cooking fish than large pieces of meat, because in order to cook it properly you need to pay attention to the eyes of the fish and the sound it makes during boiling. The size of the fish is also important, with larger fish requiring more time in your pan. Medium fish and shark meat take at least 40 seconds in the pan, while trophy fish, which are larger versions of regular fish and glow in the dark, take around 90 seconds to cook properly. You don't want to leave them on a pan for more than 80 and 180 seconds, respectively.
Kraken and Megalodon Kitchen
For those who are able to take down a Kraken or a Megalodon can jump into the water to claim a piece of the creature's meat. You can throw them in the pan, just like you would shark meat, but they take a lot longer to cook. You have to leave it there for at least two minutes. You will burn your precious encounter if you go there for more than four minutes.
